What’s a crime? What’s proof of someone having committed one? How should society and government treat those who are convicted of a crime?
These weighty questions were the substance of Justice Day, the fourth monthly session for the 2026 Class of Leadership Upper Valley (LUV), which took place in the Enfield Community Building.
As it has been for many years, LUV Justice Day was planned and led by Bobby Sand, founder of the Vermont Law and Graduate School’s Center for Justice Reform and former Vermont Governor’s Liaison to Criminal Justice Programs and Windsor County State’s Attorney, the latter a position he held for 15 years. He was joined by current Windsor County State’s Attorney Ward Goodenough and defense attorney Evan Antal of Marsicovetere & Levine Law Group, P.C., White River Junction, VT.
The State V. Jones

Discussing The State V. Edward Jones’
Bobby introduced the LUV class to the criminal justice system using the fictional case of “The State V. Edward Jones,” in which a 22-year-old man is accused of murdering his father. Participants were split into two groups, one joining Ward on the prosecution and the other joining Evan on the defense. Using the fact sheet for the case — a sad account of generational mental illness, substance abuse, and violence — the teams were instructed to choose the “most extreme sentence they could reasonably argue for” from 0-20 years. Factors such as past trauma, mental health, substance use, age, education and work history, possible threat to the community, and more were discussed.
The two teams came together for a sentencing hearing, with Bobby presiding as the judge. The prosecution made their remarks, asking for 20 years incarceration, and the defense made their remarks asking for no prison time but probation and rehabilitation requirements.
Rather than giving a sentence, however, Bobby invited everyone to step into the role of judge and anonymously write down the number of years they thought Mr. Jones should be incarcerated. While pondering that, the group was treated to a discussion by Bobby, Ward, and Evan about the differing roles of the prosecution and defense counsel. Some highlights from that discussion include:
- The prosecutor charges the accused with their crime(s).
- The defense makes sure everyone gets their due process and understands their options.
- Both are looking for an equitable outcome rather than merely to win and are balancing the impact on the community, the victim, and the defendant.
- Each state and county has different norms. In Vermont and Windsor County, the prosecution and defense tend to work well together, which is not the case everywhere.
- Many cases don’t go to trial but are settled in plea deals. In fact, if every case did go to trial, the system would be overloaded. A judge does not need to accept a plea, but they usually do.
- There is such a thing as a “trial penalty” — that, if a defendant doesn’t accept a plea deal and the case goes to trial and is convicted, they will likely face a harsher sentence than they would have received in the plea deal. Bobby added that he thinks it would be best practice for prosecutors to say upfront what they’ll ask for in sentencing if a plea isn’t agreed to so that a defendant is fully informed.
- There is at least one judge per county in VT, but judges rotate. This means that justice rotates. Going before a judge you don’t know is very different than going before a judge you do know. Judges are generally former lawyers and have specialties, although these rotations mean they hear cases outside of their specialties.
The group came back to the Jones case and read the numbers they had written. Responses included the full range of 0-20 years, with the average being around 4 or 5 years. Folks shared comments on how hard it was to decide on a sentence, how the various arguments for more or less time were all compelling, and how there are a lot more information and perspectives that were missing. It was noted that it would be helpful to hear more from Mr. Jones and other members of his family to learn how individual and family histories played a role in the crime. It was a powerful illustration of how sentences can vary drastically from one judge to another.
The group rounded out the morning with a deeper dive into why we punish and the theories of punishment:
- Retributive: Looking back at the crime and finding a proportionate punishment, the sense that offenders should pay for their crimes
- Utilitarian: Focused on the social value of punishment, such as greater public safety
- Rehabilitation: Focused on reforming offenders
- Deterrence: Essentially hoping that people will do a cost-benefit analysis before offending. Bobby shared that he thinks this isn’t relevant in many crimes, though perhaps relevant for more “white collar” crimes like embezzlement.
- Incarceration: Also called incapacitation, the theory that separating offenders from society can prevent future crimes. However, Bobby noted evidence that sending someone to jail increases their chance of going back to jail (recidivism) and shared his personal belief that incarceration is overused in the US but does make sense in some cases. This also led to a brief discussion of the “Raise the Age Movement,” which argues against trying juveniles as adults.
The Sequence of a Criminal Case
The day also included a demonstration of how a criminal case moves forward and just how many people it entails, with LUV participants standing up to represent one or more people involved in the process.
Typically, there’s the alleged victim, a police officer, the accused or defendant, prosecuting attorney or district attorney, public defender/defense attorney, a police sergeant, and four administrative folks along the way logging evidence and paperwork. Then there’s the jury. To get a jury of 12 and 2 alternates, the court starts with a pool of 40, and the process also involves staff offering pre-trial support and a judge, among others.
By the end, we counted 54 individuals for a criminal case brought to trial. We discussed some key thresholds, such as probable cause in order for an arrest to be made and the higher bar of beyond a reasonable doubt when it goes to trial. Many of the people involved in this process are paid by tax dollars. This illustrated how complex the system is and how easy it would be to “crash the system” if everyone went to trial.

Criminal Justice Vs. Justice
To dig deeper into justice and learn about alternative models than the traditional criminal justice system, the group next took part in a word association exercise. First they each shared a word that came to mind when they hear “criminal justice system.” Responses were varied but included crime, punishment, broken, overloaded, biased, law and order, and others that skewed toward a more negative connotation. Next, they shared the word that came to mind when they hear “justice.” The responses were notably more positive, including fairness, equity, repairing harm, etc.
Sharing the image of Lady Justice, Bobby noted its key features and how they might change if it reflected a more contemporary notion of justice: No sword; justice shouldn’t wield a weapon No blindfold; justice should see. No scales, because justice calls for equity more than equality. No pedestal; justice should be with people, not above.
What is Restorative Justice?
The day’s next segment was devoted to restorative justice, led by Bobby and Dan Wargo, the executive director of Valley Court Diversion Programs.
Restorative justice is based on principles including:
- Inclusive decision making
- Active accountability
- Repairing harm
- Rebuilding trust
Restorative justice asks different questions than conventional justice, such as:
- What happened? instead of What rule/law was broken?
- Who was affected and how? instead of Who did it?
- What is needed to make amends/to repair harm and make things right? instead of How can that be proved?
- How can the overall response lead to a strengthening of relationships? instead of How should they be punished?
Restorative justice is not:
- Adversarial
- Soft on crime, “slap on the wrist”
- Easy
- A per se rejection of incarceration
Bobby introduced the group to the use of the circle practice in restorative justice, which has roots in indigenous cultures throughout the world. All that’s needed are for participants to sit in a circle (it can be helpful to sit around a central object to give participants a visual focus) and to pass around a “talking piece” that people hold when it’s their turn to speak — which they can pass along if they don’t choose to speak at that moment. The group tried the process with three different prompts and reflected on its value both in restorative justice and in other situations.
Dan shared his story and how programs like the Valley Court Diversion Programs supported him to reach where he is today. The programs serve Windsor County in VT and lower Grafton County and Sullivan County in NH with the mission to strengthen our communities by promoting accountability, repair, reconciliation, and support for those who have caused harm or been affected by it. They have volunteer opportunities both in their programs and on their board.
Huge thank you to Bobby Sand, Ward Goodenough, Evan Antal, Dan Wargo, and the Town of Enfield for the great space in their Community Building!
Published 12/16/25

